Shopping·9 min read

Gifts for Dads Who Just Want a “Nice Little Something”

the best gifts for dads
Design: theSkimm | Images: Jenni Earle, Amazon, Brass Monkey
October 15, 2024

Products you buy through our links may earn us a commission. Oh, and if something's out of stock, oops, it was there (and all prices were accurate) at time of publication.

Dads can be semi-impossible to shop for. Maybe yours hasn’t even replied to your text asking what he wants for the holidays. Or maybe he said something like, “Oh, just a nice little something.” If you’re stumped on what a “nice little something” might be, don’t worry. We’ve cracked the code. Scroll on for 15 top-notch gifts for indifferent dads, husbands, and grandpas — whether yours is the type to appreciate a complex gadget, clever T-shirt, personalized book…or something completely different.

Want more holiday gifting ideas? Check out our full list of gift guides for everyone on your list.

legendary dad trophy
Jenni Earle

A legendary trophy for a legendary dad…

An accolade he’ll display with the utmost pride, this “Legendary Dad” trophy is a shoo-in for best holiday gift of the year. It’s a simple but thoughtful way to say “I love you” without getting too sappy. And the design makes it especially perfect if he’s a fan of Western movies. ($32, Jenni Earle)

$32 at Jenni Earle
Dad jokes cards
Brass Monkey

A deck of cards for a dad-joke drought…

We all know that fathers can be infinite sources of corny dad jokes…or at least that’s what they want us to think. If you’ve noticed your dad has been struggling to come up with his usual iconic quips, give him a little help with this funny pack of cards. He’ll restock his arsenal with 100 new wisecracks that you’ll have to hear for the rest of your life — but hey, at least it’s new material. ($12, Brass Monkey)

$12 at Brass Monkey
father figure t-shirt
Etsy

A funny T-shirt that gives a major confidence boost…

This cute tee is a great gift for new dads leaving their youthful bachelor days behind, or any papas who are extra proud of their father figure. It’s currently available on Etsy in  more than 10 colors and sizes up to 3XL. ($28.11+, justgottalook via Etsy)

$28.11+ at justgottalook via Etsy
dog neckerchief
Brass Monkey

For the doting dog dad…

There’s nothing like the bond between a dad and the family dog he never wanted, but fell head over heels for. This bandana is made from durable cotton so his pup can wear it and make dad proud for days. ($15, Brass Monkey)

$15 at Brass Monkey
personalized tape measure
Uncommon Goods

A practical gift that still feels personal…

It’s your standard 25-foot-long measuring tape, but with a sentimental twist. Choose from engravings that say “No One Measures Up To You” or “We Love You Beyond Measure,” and add their name and yours for a custom touch. ($38, Uncommon Goods)

$38 at Uncommon Goods
Coffee bag
Partners Coffee

For the dad who loves a good cup of coffee…

Each one of Partners’ coffee bags is roasted to order, so dad’s morning cup will taste fresher than ever before. This woman-produced coffee from Colombia is described as “floral, sweet, and well-rounded.” If he’s a coffee nerd or interested in more about the origin of these beans, he can head to Partners’ product page to get the whole story. ($26, Partners Coffee)

$26 at Partners Coffee
crossword puzzle
Uncommon Goods

For the dad dedicated to his New York Times puzzles…

If the crossword puzzle is what gets him out of bed every morning, this personalized brain teaser is sure to be a winner. When you order, submit six original clues pertaining to dad and Uncommon Goods will not only integrate them into the 56-word game, but also make them stand out among all the other answers. It’s a nice little something that will mean the world to him. ($50, Uncommon Goods)

$50 at Uncommon Goods
cash clip
Leatherology

A place to put his wad of cash…

Raise your hand if your dad refuses to leave the house without cash. Well, Leatherology’s magnetic money clip might be the perfect present. The luxe full-grain leather will hold up to 10 folded bills and keep things nice and neat so his pockets don’t have to. It comes in a lovely gift box, and you can add personalization, too. ($30+, Leatherology)

$30+ at Leatherology
Book about baseball
Amazon

For the dad who still wants to try out for the Major League…

So the man can talk about baseball for days, whether it’s the Houston Astros’ cheating scandal or his glory days as second baseman in high school. That means he’ll probably love this countdown of 50 key moments in baseball history, as chosen by New York Times bestselling author Joe Posnanski. ({{dynamicPrice}}, Amazon)

$15.99 at Amazon
tool
Leatherman

A complex contraption that can do it all…

It’s a wire cutter…no, it’s a can opener…no, it's a serrated knife. Actually, it’s all three, plus a lot more besides: It’s the Charge+ 19-in-1 tool by Leatherman. If your dad gets a kick out of fixing everything around the house, he’ll adore this tiny-but-mighty wire stripper, saw, screwdriver…you get the idea. ($159.95, Leatherman)

$159.95 at Leatherman
custom book
Uncommon Goods

A custom book that’s a tear-jerker…

If you and your partner are new parents, there’s a good chance he’ll tear up at this heartwarming book. Send in a little information in advance, and get a custom book with a sweet story about him and your new bundle of joy. You might even shed a tear during storytime, too. ($40+, Uncommon Goods)

$40+ at Uncommon Goods
leather glasses case
Leatherology

A loving home for his glasses…

This sleek leather case is so nice, he’ll never lose track of his glasses again. The soft velour interior prevents lens scratches while the premium leather exterior protects his spectacles from the outside world. ($30+, Leatherology)

$30+ at Leatherology
ice cream spoon
Etsy

For your favorite ice cream lover…

Honor his sweet tooth with this engraved metal spoon, and for an even sweeter gift, pair it with a couple pints of his favorite flavor. ($12.91, EngravingForever via Etsy)

$12.91 at EngravingForever via Etsy
Father of the year socks
Yellow Owl Workshop

An award he’ll wear with pride…

Remind Dad that he’s the best father in the world with these “Father of the Freaking Year” socks. They’re ethically sourced cotton crews with reinforced heels, toes, and cuffs, so his feet will be extra comfy. ($11.50, Yellow Owl Workshop)

$11.50 at Yellow Owl Workshop
magnetic tool-holder wristband
Amazon

A practical gift for your unofficial handyman…

If he’s ever helped you hang up a pair of shelves or mount a heavy painting, this magnetic tool wristband is a great way to say thank you. It’s equipped with 15 powerful magnets to keep every last screw, nut, and bolt secure and easily accessible. ($16.99, Amazon)

$16.99 at Amazon

Live Smarter

Sign up for the Daily Skimm email newsletter. Delivered to your inbox every morning and prepares you for your day in minutes.